Category: GLM
ILX Ramblings
A comparison of NUCAPS at 19Z with observed/analysis products from SPC showed good comparison for both modified and unmodified data. Below shows the unmodified NUCAPS sounding that was “green” over the north-central portion of the ILX CWA. The MLCAPE was around 500 J/kg, with DCAPE around 690 J/kg, freezing levels just below 10,000 feet, and PW’s around 1.1 inches.
A modified NUCAPS sounding for the same location showed an uptick in MLCAPE to around 600 J/kg, along with similar PW’s, DCAPE and freezing level.
A comparison with SPC mesoanalysis at 20Z showed very comparable PW values, between 1.1 to 1.2 inches over north-central IL, and freezing levels between 10 to 11 kft. As for MLCAPE, it appeared that for both modified and unmodified NUCAPS, the observed was higher than NUCAPS, around 1000-1500 J/kg, perhaps not having a high enough surface dewpoint. As for 850 mb temperatures, they were comparable to those observed, in the 12-14 degC range. DCAPE was also comparable in NUCAPS with what the SPC mesoanalysis page was showing, between 600-700 J/kg.
With regards to lightningCAST, ProbSevere, and GLM, around 1932Z, once again the LightningCast was showing good lead time for areas downstream of storms. The main cell at this time I was watching was in the southeast Part of our CWA, which had a nice contour of 75% to the north and east of that cell extending well north of the storm core.
At 20Z, the Optical Flow divergence field appeared to match up well with observed convection at this time. It thus showed quite well with the shear field.
ProbSevere’s time series graph continues to show added value, allowing the forecaster to see the trend in a storm’s severity and probability of severe potential. This image was at 20:40Z.
Around 21Z, I noticed a jump in GLM FED for the area of storms in the northwest part of the CWA. Alongside this, the GLM TOE also increased, along with a decrease in MFA with the same storm cell. This area corresponded with increased flash rates in the EarthNetworks. I modified the GLM FED scale to 20-25 as a maximum to see the activity better, as well as lowering TOE to 50 as a maximum.
Around 22Z, the GLM TOE showed a good correlation with the 3 strongest storms based on dBZ and ProbSevere, one to the north, and two in the far southeast, bordering Indiana. For this display of TOE, I lowered the contours to a max of 50, which seemed to work well.
Around 22:12Z, the LightningCast showed an uptick in probabilities of 75% north of a cell that was starting to show towering CU on the day cloud phase. This was before GLM and ground-based radar showed uptick in lightning activity.
Are the edges of LightningCast contours related to the detection of GLM? See below image…The contours do not close off.
Snowfan
Overview of severe weather and products for GSP
An interesting day today. Initially it did not look super favorable for severe weather, with the primary threat being wind. In the end, there was some of that along with scattered hail, but weak tornadoes were the biggest issue.
Lets start with some product evaluation. Here are screen shots in order for 21z and 22z. In each case the LHP is shown first, then HRRR, then SPC analysis. This is for CAPE at 21z and STP at 22Z.
22z
You’ll notice that the HRRR and PHS agreed well and had the right idea. The CAPE in the PHS was higher and closer to reality, but the locations were off. In the end the peak was in the middle of the CWA. Still, not bad. Similar obs can be made for STP.
Considering Prob Severe it seemed low on the tornado threat for most of the day but generally did pick up on the emerging tornado threats to a degree. Wind seemed to be running a little hot overall with only 1-2 reports but numerous storms showing decent wind probs.
This shows a few of the Prob Severe time series for possible tornadoes that were warned in real life. Day cloud phase and GLM were useful in seeing these emerging storms before they produced potential tornadoes.
This storm did eventually produce a wind report and had the highest prob wind all day.
Here is a GLM example showing the min flash area alerting me to threats before FED was showing too much.
Lastly, it is interesting to consider why we had such a prolific number of weak (potential) tornadoes along the boundary in the middle of the state. It was not particularly impressive of a set up, but something about it was quite favorable in the end. See below with up to 4 circulations at one time. (Real warnings plotted)
Some Random Guy
DSS in the Birmingham CWA
PHS
LightningCast & GLM for DSS
ProbSevere v3
NUCAPS
Optical Flow Winds
Analyzing the convective environment prior/during storm activity
I decided to look at the various parameters prior to storm initiation. When looking at PHS, it appeared our prime time for storm activity was going to be 21-00Z, when SBCAPE was forecast to be high, along with low LIs. I noticed that the STP was also elevated, upward of 3 as the activity moved northward into the southern portion of our CWA.
When comparing this to the SPC mesoanalysis page, the parameters from PHS seemed to agree fairly well with the mesoanalysis. It did appear, though, that the STP was a tad faster than what the mesoanalysis page showed. And the PHS decreased the instability an hour or two prior to 00Z, whereas the SPC page showed that instability remained elevated up to 00Z. The STP parameters in the PHS were a tad higher than the mesoanalysis page as well, with the meso page only 0.5 to 1.
A look at the NUCAPS soundings in SharpPy showed a relatively stable surface layer in observations at 12 UTC. By 1550 UTC, NUCAPS showed the surface layer to heat up from insolation but still remain largely stable.
Looking at NUCAPS gridded data, specifically for mid-level lapse rates, while the gridded data was noisy with some bullseyes, it did show the environment between 3 to 5 degC/km lapse rates, consistent with the SPC mesoanalysis page (which showed around 5.5 degC/km).
Just prior to more storm activity, GLM was picking up on a cell moving north into Wabash County, where a spike in MFA and decrease in TOE was evident. This storm was eventually warned on, where the radar showed a TBSS with a ProbSevere threshold for wind near 28%.
The lightningCast model, at least for KIWX, appeared to do better today in terms of the advection component, with the lightningCast downstream of the cells depicted in MRMS.
This time period was at 21:44Z, showing again how lightningCast was showing better predictive capabilities downstream of current convection.
Snowfan
Monitoring Scattered Convection in northern IN & Tin Caps DSS
I decided to submit a quick DSS briefing for the Fort Wayne Tin Caps with DCPD indicating glaciation and weak echoes on radar. LightningCast was starting to increase over northern IN for that weak developing convection. Additional convection is spreading in from the south, and higher LightningCast contours are also spreading in. PHS shows increased CAPE over the next hour.
Left: DCPD with GLM and LC. Right: Base reflectivity with LC
Loop of base reflectivity and LC from 1938 to 2014Z:
Left: PHS forecast CAPE at 20Z. Right: PHS LI at 20Z
First GOES flashes a little after 20Z. DCPD with GLM FED and LC
However, by 21Z, lightning is limited pretty much to cells to the northwest and E/NE of Fort Wayne.
Happily, LightningCast called the lightning flash east of Fort Wayne about 10 minutes out (small pink circle east of Fort Wayne)
Why is barely anything happening? Convection looks to be “firing” now on an instability gradient. Indicated by PHS at 21Z:
Am I confident that things will ramp up at all for our area within the next couple of hours? So-so. Here is PHS CAPE and LI for 21Z.
And gridded NUCAPS 850-500mb lapse rates at 1730Z, ranging from around 4.5-6C/km
However, zooming out, there is an area of convection across central IN that should begin approaching our southern CWA boundary within the next half hour. Here is the GLM 4 panel with GOES clean IR underlaid with the FED, at 2130Z.
– PoppyTheSmooch
Memphis, TN Synopsis
Synopsis
An upper low and cold front is expected to move across the lower MS Valley. As the upper low moves east today, weak shortwaves embedded in southwest flow will lead to a marginal risk of thunderstorms as they form along and ahead of the front over the Memphis region. The main concern was a moderate risk of excessive rainfall for this afternoon/evening.
IR imagery. Upper low located near the OK Panhandle.
Surface analysis map of the surface low and attendant front.
Surface observations as of 4:00PM CDT.
SPC Day 1 Convective placing TN at a marginal risk.
MLCAPE ~500 J/kg.
PHS displaying weak CAPE/LI values and a well-defined dry line just west of AR.
WFO Memphis headlining excessive rainfall outlook.
WFO Memphis headlining marginal risk of severe storms.
Most of the severe storms were east and south of our area of interest shown here with GLM.
GLM overlaid with Radar.
GLM overlaid with satellite imagery.
LightningCast
ProbSevere3 showing a low risk of thunderstorms.
Optical Flow winds show an area of divergence over eastern and southern AR/TN border.
Vortex Power
BMX – Daily Updates
GLM proved useful early on in combination with MRMS VII. It showed areas of strengthening storms that were reflected in radar later. A pair of severe warnings were then issued.
This was a good prob severe null case where odds remained steady along with stationary or declining GLM values. A correct no-issuance followed even with base velocity showing 50 kts or so of wind on the lowest scan. Some other prob severe oddities occurred during the day such as odd object tracking and weird percentage changes. QLCS tornado odds seemed too low as discussed. Overall though, it continues to provide useful information.
The PHS forecast again correctly identified the highest risk areas where storms strengthened and tracked. It mirrored other sources so I would still like to see if overall it is better or not.
Prob severe highlighted this storm ahead of time before it went severe in Mobile’s area.
NUCAPS provided limited use today. Overall, heavy cloud cover limited usefulness of a number of products compared to the clearer case in Texas the day before.
Some Random Guy
MAF Testbed Observations
ProbSevere v3
For the initiation of convective storms, I found that the ProbSevere performed the best over the other products available to me today. I have seen over the last couple of days that the best use of ProbSevere is the trend table. The steep increase in these total severe values support radar trends that suggest a warning is necessary. For the initial warning on severe storms, this was the best use.
The only negative to this product was the latency. While the latency was only on the order of 2-5 minutes, this was equivalent to appx. 2 radar scans that indicated to me ahead of time that this storm was strengthening. This can lead to some confusion especially if the storm is quickly pulsing and falling.
Additional upticks were noticed in subsequent SVR issuances throughout the afternoon that provided a nice heads-up in conjunction with the radar data. These were used in the context of the storm maintaining its strength after the storm was warned and again after the storm re-pulsed several minutes later.
It is also worth mentioning that the perceived threat of ProbSevere was also the shared opinion of the forecast (forecaster perceived threat for hail had the highest ProbS. probability). Once the storms reach the “cap” of their ProbSevere, it becomes of little use.
GLM
PHS Model
LightningCast
NUCAPS
Optical Flow Winds
Today’s details of products and warnings: Midland, TX
I found the PHS products useful for seeing the corridors of enhanced severe risk. They correctly showed that hail (or wind) was the highest risk compared to tornadoes.
ProbSevere was very useful with the trend lines. Again and again correctly identified risks as they occurred.
GLM showed strong ramp ups in activity prior to each severe issuance. No complaints here.
NUCAPS data was less useful, but with the skew-t pop up I was able to correctly see areas of mid level dry air. I did not use optical flow. Prob lightning was useful to see the first cells pop up but did not serve as much purpose after that with no known DSS opportunities.
Some Random Guy
