Today I tried to focus on the LightningCast and Stoplight Charts by comparing them. I noticed that in the case of lightning approaching, the probabilities on the dashboard went up. While version 2 in Figure 1 shows a blip around 20:15z, this was validated by a storm up to the north of the Airport which had lightning near 10 miles of the site. Version 1 had more of a persistent gradual increase which began sooner than Version 2. Version 1 would have most likely given more of a lead time than a quick ramp up.
Figure 2 represents the same timestamp as Figure 1 and shows the lightning increasing in coverage as storms approach. Figure 3 is a screenshot of the current lightning and LightningCast probabilities. The Stoplight Chart did very well with the area that the lightning was occurring.
Figures 4-6 show similar images but this time as the storms passed by. One thing I noticed was the LightningCast probabilities dropped off dramatically while lightning was still around the area. The lightning Stoplight Chart, in my opinion, handled the ramp down better with a more gradual end to the lightning.
So, it was interesting to see that both of them did fairly well ramping up lightning probabilities which increases confidence in forecasting and giving lead time for lightning DSS. However, there was a noticeable difference with the end time since the Stoplight Chart kept showing red over the area, meaning lightning was either nearby or occurring whereas the LightningCast rapidly dropped probabilities.
Overall, they both did well and they were both useful with lead/end times of lightning.
Figure 3: LightningCast showed the probabilities of lightning pretty well as lightning was occurring and approaching the site.
