The top image below depicted a few marginal severe storms in western Arkansas,  The storm of interest is the one farthest west between the two other cells that were located slightly to the east.  ProbSevere gave this storm 9% chance of being severe in an environment with 898 J/kg, 27.4 kt of ENShear, MRMS MESH of 0.53 in, 1.27%/min normal vertical growth rate, and 0.03/in glaciation rate.

This storm produced quarter size (1 in diameter).  MESH underestimated the hail size in this case.  I (as well as the WFO Little Rock) did not issue a warning of this storm thinking the hail size was a bit smaller (closer to pennies – 0.75 in or nickels – 0.88 in).  The environment was characterized by the 12 UTC LZK (Little Rock) sounding below (bottom image) with a freezing level of 6579 ft AGL and -20C level at 15572 ft AGL, conducive for the development of hail.

The ProbSevere seemed to be too low in this case, only with a value of 9%. I would personally estimate the ProbSevere closer to 30 or 40% for this storm, especially considering that the reflectivities 16-17 kft AGL were 55-60 dbz (I typically use 60 dbz or greater at the -20C level as a proxy for issuing severe thunderstorm warnings for large hail.)

Michael Scotten